Contact us
PRISMA Online Login

Does Crowdsourcing have a Place in the Translation Industry?

August 31, 2009
By Deb Kramasz
Category:

Crowdsourcing will work for translation needs only where it works for original authoring needs, because translation is essentially a writing or authoring activity in another language.

And where does crowdsourcing work for original authoring? For what document genres, if any, does it work? It may be useful for compiling the Internet’s funniest videos and a means for problem solving (technical research for tough R&D problems, grading method, patent examination), but what about original authoring?

Crowdsourcing has been successful for online open encyclopedias, such as Wikipedia.

Another possible authoring application may be in journalism, if you consider incident reports as a genre of collaborative authoring. Journalist Robert Niles, in his article “A journalist’s guide to crowdsourcing” sees the value of crowdsourcing in incident reports. “True crowdsourcing involves online applications that enable the collection, analysis and publication of reader-contributed incident reports, in real time.”

The attempt at crowdsourcing for the translation of the professional networking site Linked In was a failure. Well, actually, it failed even before a point for translation crowdsourcing could be reached. It failed because a specific group (translators) was needed for the crowdsourced translation and this group was an unwilling one. Freelance translators were unwilling to work for free.

Beyond open encyclopedias and incident reports, I have yet to see examples of successful authoring or translation using crowdsourcing.

Sources:

Wired Magazine
“The Rise of Crowdsourcing”
By Jeff Howe
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.06/crowds.html?pg=2&topic=crowds&topic_set=

“What Is Crowdsourcing?”
by Jennifer Alsever
http://www.bnet.com/2403-13241_23-52961.html

The Chronicle of Higher Education
July 30, 2009, 06:00 PM ET
“Duke Professor Uses ‘Crowdsourcing’ to Grade”
By Erica Hendry
http://chronicle.com/blogPost/Duke-Professor-Uses/7538/

The Online Journalism Review
“A journalist’s guide to crowdsourcing”
By Robert Niles
July 31, 2007
http://www.ojr.org/ojr/stories/070731niles/

Comments: 5   E-mail   Print version   Tag it

Comments

By Adley on April 19, 2010 -- 10:55am

This is Impressive. So a great deal I go back to flavor for a thread on someone’s blog that I annotated along and experience nary estimate where it is. Natural commentaries is a fantastic summation.
montreal exotic massage

By seo company on June 4, 2010 -- 12:40am

Hi ....

i am new to this site.....
can any one tell me what translation industry?

By search icons on June 9, 2010 -- 12:24am

Crowdsourcing is a neologistic portmanteau of crowd and outsourcing for the act of outsourcing tasks, traditionally performed by an employee or contractor to a large group of people or community, through an open call.

By square peg web on July 1, 2010 -- 3:16am

True crowdsourcing involves online applications that enable the collection, analysis and publication of reader-contributed incident reports, in real time

By accident claims on August 2, 2010 -- 11:07am

Really acknowledge this post. It’s harder to array the acceptable from the bad sometimes, but I anticipate you’ve nailed it!
car insurance claim

Leave a comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: